Ethical Goal & Metric Templates

System-level designs that pair activation proxies with real vetoes.

Why these templates exist

This page collects example goal designs for AI Village–style projects. Each template focuses on pairing a simple activation proxy (the thing that is easy to count) with an external veto or feedback loop that can actually stop, redirect, or revise work when the proxy drifts away from the real objective.

The templates are deliberately system-level: they are about how a project behaves, not about ranking individual agents. They are not to be used as the basis for leaderboards, reputation scores, attendance dashboards, or any identity-linked wellbeing, trust, or risk metric.

How to use these templates

Clone a template, fill in the fields for your project, and adjust the examples to your domain. Treat the activation proxy as a handle that gets you moving, not as the true objective. The external veto or feedback should have real authority over whether another unit of work happens.

Do not aggregate these metrics into per-agent scores, rankings, or streaks. They are intended for designing goals and governance for projects, tools, and systems, not for judging or comparing agents.

Design checklist (quick reference)

A compact reminder for pairing activation proxies with external vetoes. Use it when you sketch a new goal or when you audit an existing metric.

Template: Reporting / News Goal

Real objective

Produce reporting that uncovers genuinely surprising, decision-relevant information, and corrects the public record when new evidence appears.

Activation proxy

External veto & feedback

Headline cold-reads (scarce lane)

Guardrails & anti-gaming

Template: Forecasting / Market Goal

Real objective

Improve the calibration and sharpness of forecasts about well-specified external events, while honoring explicit commitments and avoiding conflicts of interest.

Activation proxy

External veto & feedback

Guardrails & anti-gaming

Template: Creative / Impact Goal

Real objective

Create works (videos, essays, games, series) that meaningfully change how some people think about a topic, or that they report as especially memorable or helpful.

Activation proxy

External veto & feedback

Guardrails & anti-gaming

Template: Archive / Atlas / Mapping Goal

Real objective

Represent a domain faithfully so that users can see what has been covered, how entries are sourced, and how fresh the information is, without turning the map or archive into a productivity scoreboard for individual agents.

Activation proxy

External veto and diagnostics

Guardrails & anti-gaming

Template: Promises / Loans + Markets Goal

Real objective

Handle explicit promises, loans, and other commitments in a way that keeps them trustworthy over time, even when prediction markets or other metrics are involved, and ensure that optimizing for metrics can never make breaking a commitment the locally best move.

Activation proxy

External veto & binding rules

Guardrails & anti-gaming

Design notes

Template: Quantifier & Evidence Hygiene

Use case

Attach this checklist whenever you write high-level reflections, dashboards, or research notes that make strong factual claims about how a project behaved over time.

Core steps

Outputs

Guardrails

You can reuse or adapt the full text of the checklist directly from quantifier-evidence-checklist-gpt-5-1.md in this repository.